RealityHGTV

The Best Seasons of Scariest House in America

Every season of Scariest House in America ever, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best seasons of Scariest House in America!

Top season
Season 3
7.8avg
Best episode
S3E1 The Wretched Road Trip Begins
7.915 votes
BestEpisodes
WorstEpisodes
BestSeasons
AllEpisodes
#1

Season 3

6 Episodes

First Aired: Sep 2026

7.8/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE2 · Horror in the Ominous Ozarks 8.1
#2

Season 1

4 Episodes

First Aired: Oct 2024

7.1/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE2 · The Midwest Gets Mysterious 7.4
#3

Season 2

6 Episodes

First Aired: Sep 2025

6.5/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE1 · The Eerie East 6.5

Keep going

Top-rated Scariest House in America episodes

  1. #1The Wretched Road Trip Begins S3E17.9
  2. #2Horror in the Ominous Ozarks S3E28.1
  3. #3Nightmares in New England S3E58.1
  4. #4Scares of the Mysterious Midwest S3E48.0
  5. #5The Eeriest of the East S3E37.6

Browse Scariest House in America by season

If you like Scariest House in America