People Magazine Investigates S9E4 — Playing with Fire

7.5

People Magazine Investigates•Season 9•Episode 4

Playing with Fire

7.5/10 · 37 votesFeb 2, 202643 min

Ranked #3 of 12 in Season 9•+0.1 vs season avg

Discussion

In 2001, someone murders a father, sets his Florida home ablaze, and his sons disappear. As prayers rise for their safe return, a so-called family friend steps forward, shifting the case. Now, an exclusive interview finally uncovers the chilling truth.

Previous episodeE3 · Sex House Homicide Next episodeE5 · The Serial Killer Who Only Killed Once

Seasons9

All 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Season 9 Episodes12

E1 7.4

Vanished in the Heartland

E2 7.5

Death in Hell's Kitchen

E3 6.6

Sex House Homicide

E4 7.5Now viewing

Playing with Fire

E5 7.4

The Serial Killer Who Only Killed Once

Looking for Angela

The Girl on the Bike

The Final Cut

Love, Lies, and Lust

Deadly Ride

The Truth is in the Dirt

No image

E12 7.4

Where is Judith?

Discussion

0 comments

Join the conversation

Share your take and reply to other fans.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this episode.

Episode Summary

"Playing with Fire" is episode 4 of People Magazine Investigates season 9. It scored 7.5/10 from 37 votes, ranking #3 of 12 episodes this season (season average 7.4). It aired on February 2, 2026.

Next: E5 · The Serial Killer Who Only Killed Once Best of Season 9