Taken: Carlie Brucia

7.3/10 · 10 votesAug 18, 202545 min

Ranked #4 of 10 in Season 3•+0.4 vs season avg

Discussion

In 2004, 11-year-old Carlie Brucia is kidnapped while walking home in Sarasota, Florida. Her body is found days later. The killer is Joseph Smith was a released convict on probation.

Previous episodeE3 · In Plain Sight: Breck Bednar Next episodeE5 · Uninvited: The Petit Family

Seasons3

All 1 2 3

Season 3 Episodes10

E1 6.1

Where Mercy Died: Sean McKay

E2 5.4

A Mother's Absence: Michelle Gunshon

E3 7.3

In Plain Sight: Breck Bednar

E4 7.3Now viewing

Taken: Carlie Brucia

E5 7.3

Uninvited: The Petit Family

E6 7.0

Without a Trace: Kelsey Smith

E7 6.6

Unforgotten: Mandy Stavik

E8 7.7

Targeted: Beverly Carter

E9 7.6

Love & Hate: Philip Walsted

E10 6.5

A Father's Love: Jorge Rodriguez

Discussion

0 comments

Join the conversation

Share your take and reply to other fans.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this episode.

Episode Summary

"Taken: Carlie Brucia" is episode 4 of Murdered at First Sight season 3. It scored 7.3/10 from 10 votes, ranking #4 of 10 episodes this season (season average 6.9). It aired on August 18, 2025.

Next: E5 · Uninvited: The Petit Family Best of Season 3