Is It Cake? Halloween poster

RealityNetflix

The Best Episodes of Is It Cake? Halloween Season 1

Every episode of Is It Cake? Halloween Season 1 ranked from best to worst. Discover the Best Episodes of Is It Cake? Halloween Season 1!

Binge this in 2h 36m·Peaking at 6.8/10

Seasons2

#1 Fan Favorite
6.8/10(49 votes)
#1 - Cakes to Die For
S1:E110/8/2025
The competition begins as the bakers craft convincingly creepy dolls, clowns, and ravens. Guest judges: Pete Holmes, Chelsea Peretti and Ravi V. Patel.
Director:Rich Kim
Writer:Unknown
Be the first to start the conversation for this episode
Director:Rich Kim
Writer:Unknown
6.4/10(36 votes)
#2 - Is It Wonka?
S1:E310/8/2025
The bakers tape into their pure imagination and whip up whimsical Willy Wonka cakes. Guest judges: Harvey Guillén, Kevin Nealon and Gillian Jacobs.
Director:Rich Kim
Writer:Unknown
Be the first to start the conversation for this episode
Director:Rich Kim
Writer:Unknown
6.4/10(40 votes)
#3 - A Scary Good Winner
S1:E410/8/2025
Vultures, gargoyles and gravestones, oh my! Which baker will take home the grand prize? Guest judges: Ron Funches, Rachel Feinstein and Whitney Cummings.
Director:Rich Kim
Writer:Unknown
Be the first to start the conversation for this episode
Director:Rich Kim
Writer:Unknown
6.2/10(41 votes)
#4 - Gettin' Witchy with It!
S1:E210/8/2025
Mikey's fickle "cauldron of destiny" decides which witchy object the bakers must make. Guest judges: Melissa Joan Hart, Jack McBrayer and Yvonne Orji.
Director:Rich Kim
Writer:Unknown
Be the first to start the conversation for this episode
Director:Rich Kim
Writer:Unknown

Season 1 Ratings Summary

"Cakes to Die For" is the best rated episode of Is It Cake? Halloween season 1. It scored 6.8/10 from 49 votes. Directed by Rich Kim and written by Unknown, it aired on October 8, 2025. This episode is rated 0.4 points higher than the second-best, "Is It Wonka?".